Pool Controller and Spa Controller - AquaSense

With the latest pool and spa controllers from Pi you can often achieve a 3 month pay back, both reducing your costs and improving the bathing experience of your pool users.

For many years cheap sensors and controllers have prevailed in the pool industry leading to poor quality bathing water and a poor quality bathing experience.

Often operators don’t know how poor their controllers are, thinking that the poor performance is normal. Pi use the same sensors for controlling chlorine in swimming pools as we use for controlling chlorine in drinking water. Based on their superior sensors and controllers, Pi can:

• Save money by controlling pool recirculating pumps
• Eliminate bacteriological growths in pools and spas
• Optimize the chemical usage
• Eliminate ‘red eye’ and chlorine smells

The AquaSense is a sophisticated device capable of controlling many aspects of the pool including the chlorine levels, the pH and if a variable speed device is fitted, the speed of the recirculating pumps.

Most pool recirculating pumps are over specified for the duty required and as such there is scope to turn them down and save considerable amounts of money on the electricity usage. Whenever you save electricity you are reducing the CO₂ emissions and the carbon footprint of your pool and spa, and for many organizations reducing CO₂ emissions is a significant factor in choosing which equipment to purchase.

In order to turn down the pool recirculating pump the pump motor must be fitted with an inverter. The question then arises – on what basis do we turn the motor down? Each pool has a minimum turnover set by the manufacturer or consultant at the time of installation. The CRIUS^® AquaSense allows the user to turn down the recirculating pump during periods of non pool use (overnight) to the minimum level. Whilst the pool is being used the recirculating pump motor speed is set based on chlorine demand (which is proportional to bathing load). This ability to control the recirculating pump based on chlorine demand means that pool operators can save significant sums of money on electricity during the day when electricity costs the most. This can lead to a three month pay back on some pools. Please contact your local sales team for references.

Many leisure facilities are now fitted with sophisticated BMS (Building Management Systems) and Pi’s pool and spa controllers are able to communicate directly to the BMS whatever system it might be. Every AquaSense from Pi can come equipped with inverter control and a range of communication protocols including LAN, Profibus, Modbus and more traditional analogue and digital outputs.

Save Money and the planet! Most pool recirculating pumps are over specified for the duty required and as such there is scope to turn them down and save considerable amounts of money on the electricity usage. Whenever you save electricity you are reducing the CO₂ emissions and carbon footprint of your pool and spa and for many organizations reducing CO₂ emissions is a significant factor in choosing which equipment to purchase. It might not really save the planet but it is a good start! In order to turn down the pool recirculating pump the pump motor must be fitted with an inverter. The question then arises – on what basis do we turn the motor down?

Each pool has a minimum turnover set by the manufacturer or consultant at the time of installation. The CRIUS^® AquaSense allows the user to turn down the recirculating pump during periods of non pool use (overnight) to the minimum level using the built-in inverter control algorithms. While the pool is being used the recirculating pump motor is set based on chlorine demand which is proportional to bathing load. This ability to control the inverter and therefore the recirculating pump based on chlorine demand means that pool operators can save significant sums of money on electricity during the times when electricity costs the most. Saving on chemical use can also be significant. The AquaSense inverter control is the most complete, sophisticated and effective currently available anywhere in the world.

The AquaSense can also be fitted with other sensors depending on the needs of your pool or spa. These may include for example

• Particle Counters (filter optimization)
• Turbidity (clarity optimization)
• Streaming Current (coagulant optimization)
• UV254 Transmission (UV disinfection optimization)
• Ozone (disinfection control)
• Chlorine Dioxide (disinfection control)
• TDS (Total Dissolved Solids)

Did you know…

… that PID can save you money by offering better process control?
… that PID can help you maintain a setpoint, even with a variable process?
… that the days of over complex and confusing PID are over?
… that Pi can tailor a PID system to your exact requirements? You may never have to touch those settings again!

In this Focus On, Pi would like to introduce you to PID if you haven’t come across it, and discuss some of the useful advanced features of modern PID systems, like on Pi’s CRONOS^® and CRIUS^® models for those more familiar with PID.

What is PID?

PID is a mathematical tool created by engineers and is used in controllers. It is a feature often found in industrial controllers and is available in Pi’s controllers, as an inexpensive upgrade.

What is PID for?

The best way to explain what PID does, is to take an example. Most people have been to a swimming pool at some point in their lives, so this is the example we shall use. PID is also applicable in a huge variety of other processes. If you are not sure, you can always contact us to discuss your application.

When a person enters a swimming pool, they create a chlorine demand. They do this by introducing sweat, bacteria, organic molecules and other substances into the pool water. Chlorine reacts with these substances, which results in chlorine being used up and the chlorine level dropping. The chlorine level in this example, is often called the process variable or PV in the context of PID.

In order to maintain a concentration or level of chlorine, more chlorine needs to be dosed. If you dosed the same amount of chlorine per bather, the level would not be stable as all bathers create a different chlorine demand (e.g. swimming for fitness produces more sweat than swimming recreationally). Dosing manually brings in the issue of human error, and how operators approximate or calculate the amount of chlorine to dose based on current levels. Another issue with manual dosing is that it is not a continuous process, meaning it is unlikely a stable level will ever be reached.

What does PID do?

PID takes the measured level of chlorine or the PV and compares it to the desired level or set-point. This comparison gives the error which PID interprets and then calculates an output. The output is an electrical signal which controls the dosing of the appropriate chemical. The output can control heaters, dosing pumps and many other mechanisms that can be used to change the PV.

How is PID used?

PID is made up of three parts, proportional, integral and derivative. Understanding what each part does helps operators choose the level of control best suited to them.

Proportional

Is the most commonly used for portion PID and suits most applications. When using proportional control, the further away the measured value is from the setpoint, the larger the output will be from the controller. This is an appropriate level of control for most processes, and users can gain a lot of control from a purely proportional system.

In some systems where the PV is lost to the process, e.g. chlorine from a pool, heat from a boiler etc., the proportional control never quite catches up with the setpoint. Users can see that although the process approaches the setpoint it rarely, if ever, gets to it. This is known as ‘droop’. The user can compensate for droop if the removal of the PV is fairly constant, simply by raising the setpoint, e.g. evaporation of chlorine from an empty pool. If droop changes often, (e.g. bather load or chlorine demand) then to eradicate the ‘droop’ then the integral part of PID can be applied to the signal to correct it.

Integral

The output from the integral term is determined by both the magnitude and the duration of the error. A small error over a long period of time will trigger a larger response than from a purely proportional system. This helps the elimination of the ‘droop’ seen in processes with continuous loss, and also serves to help reach the setpoint quicker.

Derivative

Derivative gain is rarely used and is generally set up only by expert engineers. Derivative gain uses the rate of change in the PV to try and predict future errors. This type of control is particularly susceptible to overcompensating, especially if there is even a small amount of signal noise (usually seen as spikes in the PV). Derivative gain is generally a tweak used by engineers to improve an already tight control, and is almost never used as an essential part of control.

What are the benefits of PID?

When properly set up, PID can lead to far tighter process control, which in turn can save you time and money. As an example, pool managers want to keep chlorine levels low, to improve the bathing experience and also save on chemicals. AquaSense is a chlorine analyzer system that responds quickly and appropriately to a change in bather load (also known as chlorine demand). This means pool operators can save money whilst maintaining the safety of the pool. PID can also help reduce the risk of overshooting the desired setpoint, reducing the risk of dangerous overdosing of the chemicals.

Advanced Features and Safeguards

Whilst maintaining a setpoint with a PID loop is a huge advance over using threshold relays to maintain an upper and lower limit, it is sensible to control the loop with extra safeguards, such as:

• Maximum and minimum pump outputs. This is mainly used to prevent the controller from employing too aggressive a control, which can lead to overdosing. A minimum output can also be used in a system where the measured parameter is lost over time, to prevent the controller ever turning the dosing off.
• Ramp rate is a proportional control that allows users to choose how quickly or slowly the controller doses, in order to reach the setpoint. It is especially useful on startup, and can prevent the controller dosing too quickly.
• Wind up protection is an integral control, which limits the duration aspect of the control. This puts a limit on how much previous error can accumulate. Without wind up protection, there could be a very large integral value, if the process ever reaches zero or on startup.

These are all standard features in all Pi PID controllers.

Conclusion

In summary, PID is a very useful tool when used correctly, and can result in significant chemical savings, not to mention reduced pump wear and tear and lower electricity costs.

A VSD is an electronic device which enables the pump motor to be turned up or down thus increasing or lowering the pump speed.

Most pool recirculating pumps are over specified for the duty required and as such, there is scope using VSDs to turn them down when possible and save considerable amounts of money on electricity costs.

Did you know that…

… VSD control has saved some swimming pools more than 35% on their electricity bills?
… Pi’s VSD control saves money during the night and even during the day when electricity tariffs are highest?
… VSD control is available on both Pi’s CRONOS^® and CRIUS^® controllers?

The Problem : HIgh Electricity Bills & High CO2 Footprint.

High electricity bills and high CO₂ footprint.
Most swimming pools and spas spend considerable amounts of money on electricity to run their pool water recirculation pumps. These pumps are often over specified, running at full power even when there are few or no bathers using the pool or spa during the daytime. With recirculation pumps continually running at full power, the monthly electricity bills can be very high. A result of this high electricity demand is an increased carbon footprint of the pool or spa. Current VSD controls only lower the pump speeds to reduce the pool or spa’s water recirculation to a minimum overnight when there are no bathers.

The Solution: Pi’s CRONOS® & CRIUS® Controllers with VSD

Process Instruments’ CRONOS^® and CRIUS^® Controllers with VSD
What is required is a VSD control which in addition to reducing power consumption overnight can also save costs during the day by turning the pumps down when there are few bathers.

Pi’s controllers have the capability to utilize the VSD control during the day and at night; swimming pools and spas can benefit from turning the pumps down even during the day when electricity costs are highest.

How does VSD control work?

Pi’s VSD control sets the recirculation pump motor automatically, while the pool is being used, based on biocide demand. Biocide demand is directly linked to the number of people using the pool or spa, therefore Pi’s controllers can reduce pump speeds and electricity costs during periods of fewer bathers.

The graph shows how VSD control works, based on biocide demand. Looking at the graph, thresholds are set at different levels of biocide. These thresholds are then used to create biocide level bands, with each band being attributed with a specific pump speed. This optimizes water recirculation whilst maintaining the minimum turnover set by the manufacturer or consultant at the time of installation. During daytime periods when the number of pool users fluctuates, the bather load increases/decreases respectively. As the biocide demand is directly proportional to the bather load, fewer users will result in biocide levels dropping below the band threshold thus enabling a reduced pump speed during the day. Pi’s VSD control exploits this relationship between biocide demand and bather load adjusting the pumps speeds during the day hence saving the pool or spa money on electricity.

In addition to pools and spas saving money on their electricity, they are effectively reducing CO₂ emissions and the carbon footprint of their establishment. For many organizations, reducing CO₂ emissions is a significant factor in choosing which equipment to purchase.

Swimming Pool Application Savings Data

For a commercial swimming pool (210m³) the monthly savings on electricity using VSD control were calculated.

The power consumption of the recirculation pump was recorded for a month with Pi’s VSD control enabled and without VSD for the same period. Using standard day and night electricity tariffs, it was possible to calculate how much money can be saved by this feature.

Over a period of a month, energy costs were calculated.

From these results it can be seen that Pi’s VSD control saved £213 a month at this single commercial swimming pool. This is a significant reduction not only in cost but also the CO₂ footprint of the site. The larger the pool and spa, the bigger the pump that is required to recirculate, therefore the more money that can be saved on electricity. Using the VSD control; Pi’s controllers could pay for themselves in 6 months or less.